Saturday, March 7, 2015

The (Stereo)Typical Asian American

Surprise! There has been yet another change in plans! Instead of administering a survey, as written in my original proposal, I will be focusing solely on a literature review of Asian American racial socialization. For the next couple weeks, I will continue to gather publications and will start going through them to find trends and create classifications for the different types of socialization used by Asian American families.

In order to distinguish whether the socialization involves more assimilation into "American" culture, we must first define what being "American" is. According to a study by Devos and Banaji (2005), most people, when asked to list "American" characteristics, talk about democracy, individuality, equality, capitalism, the American Dream, the 4th of July, the Superbowl, hot dogs, McDonald's, etc.

America in a picture.

Almost no one, however, brings up race as a factor of being "American." This is interesting because when asked to do the same for "Korean" or "British," one of the first answers to pop up is race. Koreans are a type of Asians; British are a type of Europeans. But, since America is a melting pot of different races, there is no clear definition of what it means to be "American."

On the other hand, most people claim to know what it means to be "Asian." What kind of racial stereotypes are Asian American families up against? These are the most common stereotypes of Asian people:

Perpetual Foreigner
Asians are seen to be exotic, and alien in their own land. This stereotype usually leads to questions like "Where are you really from?" (As if the word "really" would change the fact that my Asian American friend was born in Arizona.) In the media, most Asians play ninjas or kung fu masters, further supporting this stereotype, if they're not doctors or nerds like the next category.
A rare exception from the stereotype: Minho (Ki Hong Lee) from The Maze Runner

Model Minority Myth
Most people strongly believe that Asians are naturally smart and highly motivated. This meme says it all:

However, the Model Minority Myth was created during the Civil Rights Movement to justify the unfair treatment of African Americans. The argument was that if Asian Americans were so successful despite unequal circumstances, why couldn't African Americans do the same? Although this logic is completely flawed, people today still think Asians are smarter.

Hyper/hypo-sexualization 
Asian women are presumed to be more feminine, while Asian men are seen as less masculine. Even worse, many Asian men are thought to be gay. First of all, not all Asian men are less masculine than White men. Also, masculinity and sexual orientation are two completely different subjects that have no definite correlation.

Out-group Homogeneity
Are you guys sisters? No. Just because we're both Asian, doesn't mean we're related. This picture draws from the out-group homogeneity stereotype, as well as hyper/hypo-sexualization:

Communication Style
Because of the collectivist culture of many Asian countries, Asian people are often presumed to be too quiet, passive, or indirect. This stereotype originates from the language barrier that most Asian immigrants experience when they first move to America. If a White person, born and raised in America, visited China, he might not speak as much as he does in America because of the language barrier. Communication style depends much more on personality than race.

The culmination of all of these stereotypes (except satirized and applied to a White person) can be found in this video:

9 comments:

  1. I love videos that turn things on their heads and give everyone perspective. And the communication style part is such an important thing that no one thinks about! So will the end product of your project be the different classifications of socialization?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. As of right now, yes. I will try to classify the different types of racial socialization in specifically Asian American families.

      Delete
  2. Best of luck as you slightly alter the focus of your SRP. It's wild to think there are people who would say such things, but I think racial stereotypes can become the easiest (and maybe sometimes somewhat accurate way) to talk to someone new, even if they are often, if not always, harmful and degrading to the other person. It's definitely something I should check myself for as I meet hordes of new people in college. I found your mentioning of comparing Asian minority success to African American minority success very interesting, mainly because it's an argument I personally heard myself before. Keep up the great work Julie!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. To be honest, I do that too. But, I'm trying to be a little more careful as I learn more. Thanks, Ali!

      Delete
  3. I didn't know that the Model Minority Myth was actually created for that reason. As awful as that is, it's interesting to see how different races are held to different standards of intelligence. Even though the Model makes no sense whatsoever, I feel that the Model itself would explain why African-Americans, on average, have low confidence in themselves when it comes to being intelligent since there’s this stigma concerning their natural ability that’s been around since the Civil Rights Movement. Regardless, thank you for the history lesson! 

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah! The Model Minority Myth is not only harmful to Asian Americans, but to many African Americans as well!

      Delete
  4. It's interesting to see how you've spun your project more to literature, and I can't wait to see what you come up! Also, your explanations were super interesting to read. I've seen all of those stereotypes in real life and I knew of them, but to really see them separated and made distinct, while deeply explaining each in detail, really helps shed a new light to each! While this isn't the most "scientific" of sources, I saw this poem on tumblr, and as soon as I saw it, I thought of you and your project, so I thought you may enjoy reading it and be able to relate to some of the things being said or give some of your insight on it possibly (though it's definitely not something you'd use for a school project, what with the harsher language).

    Anyways, I can't wait to see more of your project! :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Woah. That poem was definitely relatable, even though I'm fully Asian. Thanks for sharing it!

      Delete
  5. I am a senior in Lutheran High School-Parker, and I am a Chinese international student. Even though I study in America, I don’t know about the stereotype towards Asian very well. I can see where the model minority myth and hyper/hypo-sexualization come from, but the stereotype that considered Asian American to be exotic really surprise me. Still, it makes sense to me. In America, Asians are not politically and socially engaging. There are not many Asians pursue their political ambition and seek to make any kind of social reform. Traditionally, Asian tends to avoid confrontation. There are good things come with it, there are not as many social conflicts concerning Asian as it is concerning other race, like black. But come with the price that Asian, as a ethical group, don’t have a strong voice in the society.

    ReplyDelete